Can I offer both ICHRA and a group plan?

Yes — but not to the same class of employees. You can offer a group plan to one class and an ICHRA to another, within the class rules.

Will employees be worse off with ICHRA?

Often they’re better off because they choose their own plan and network. The change is that they enroll individually — which a broker makes easy.

Does ICHRA satisfy the employer mandate?

An affordable ICHRA can satisfy the ACA employer mandate for applicable large employers. A broker can confirm affordability for your specific allowance.

Comparison

ICHRA vs group insurance: which should you offer?

Group health insurance pools your employees into one plan; an ICHRA gives each employee a tax-free allowance to buy their own. The trade-off is control and predictability versus a single managed plan. Here’s how they compare and how to choose.

The core trade-off

With group insurance, the employer owns one plan and absorbs annual premium increases, but employees get a familiar, hands-off experience. With ICHRA, the employer sets a fixed budget and employees choose their own plan — more predictable for you, more choice for them, but it asks employees to enroll individually.

When group insurance still makes sense

You’re large enough to get favorable group rates and want to pool risk.
Your team strongly prefers a single, employer-managed plan.
You can absorb and budget for annual renewal increases.

When ICHRA is the better fit

You want fixed, predictable benefits costs with no renewal surprises.
Your team is spread across states or works variable hours.
You can’t meet group-plan participation minimums.
You want employees to choose plans and networks that fit their families.

The verdict

Choose ICHRA for predictable costs and employee choice. Choose group insurance if you want one employer-managed plan and can absorb annual premium increases.

Feature	ICHRA	Group insurance
Who picks the plan	Each employee	The employer (one plan for all)
Cost predictability	Fixed budget you set	Subject to annual renewal increases
Participation minimums	None	Often 70%+ participation required
Multi-state teams	Works in all 50 states	Can be complex across states
Employee choice	Full choice of individual plans	Limited to the chosen group plan
Tax treatment	Tax-free reimbursements	Tax-advantaged premiums
Admin burden	Reimbursement + substantiation	Plan management + renewals

Want this set up for your team?

Get a Free Quote

Frequently asked questions

It can be, but the bigger difference is predictability: with ICHRA you set a fixed budget instead of absorbing annual group-premium increases. Whether it’s cheaper depends on your team and the allowance you choose.

Ready to offer health benefits the modern way?

Tell us about your team and get a free, no-obligation ICHRA quote.